3 Comments
User's avatar
Eleanor Rivers's avatar

Welcome to the LightHouse, Paul. For a first essay, you did what this Island rarely gets from anyone in authority: you walked down to the south end, looked, took pictures, asked questions, and wrote down who didn't answer.

Where I part ways with you, gently, is the park. I want RIOC to tell us its plans, and I want those walls kept standing. But the south end is one of the last places on this Island where something lives without a ticket or a tram schedule. We have enough foot traffic and enough tourists already. The animals who have made that ruin their home never asked for a visitor center, and I'd rather RIOC protect their freedom than invite more of us in to stare at it.

Keep writing. I'd like some company before I'm declared a landmark myself.

Esther Greenwood's avatar

Great article, Paul and Theo!

David Stone's avatar

RIOC, long ago, made clear its intentions of investing no more funds into the ruins than legally necessary to keep the walls standing. It's been a money pit ever since it got an historic designation it doesn't deserve. This was clearly expressed by CEO Steve Shane when RIOC was forced to put up emergency fixtures after a storm knocked some of it down.

Despite Martin's puffery -- and please keep in mind that Four Freedoms Conservancy rejected his proposal because the building does not warrant such a huge investment -- it is important to note that only the middle third of the building was designed by Renwick. The deeply unimpressive wings were added much later, and he played no role in them. And supporters also fail to acknowledge that the ground under the ruins are contaminated. When RIOC built out Southpoint in 2011, it mitigated the contamination in the active areas with an apron that may or may not prevent surface exposure. (Conveniently, RIOC has failed to test for leakage.) But in any case, the fence surrounding the ruins also fences in soil contaminated by decades of use of the ruins and the structures that preceded it. Where are the Friends cost estimates for testing and treatment for that? You guessed it. No plans, let alone acknowledgement, exist.

It's startling that, after all this time, Martin has no actual plans, just appeals for money. (Anyone can imagine better uses for the $30+ million price tag.) There is no legitimate use that would justify the money. That's why, after more than a decade of appeals, only a tiny amount, collected some years ago, is all the Friends have to show for it.

That said, because of historic preservation designations by folks without a dime invested, RIOC can't unload this heap of rock. Roosevelt Islanders will be stuck with maintaining it in perpetuity unless an earthquake finally does it in. This space could be a nature park, a playground, a stage for performances. Instead, it's a now and forever eyesore. Don't invest in making it even worse.