4 Comments
User's avatar
David Stone's avatar

Beautifully written, and I'm sorry I could not respond sooner. (I was in the hospital after surgery)

In my view, that is, of someone who once knew and liked David Kraut and still knows and likes Susan Rosenthal, the difference here is in loyalties. As Kraut became older and angrier, he lost tolerance for others with different views. He told me I was on his "shit list" and refused to cooperate on an article about his service with RIOC. I had long ago done one on Patrick Stewart, a man Kraut's equal in many ways but kinder and more generous who died too young.

Susan was my friend before, during and after her dismissal, despite my having written numerous critical articles about her. She understood her job as well as mine and did not hold grudges. On one of our last chats before her firing, she gave me some of the best advice I will ever receive. I will owe thanks forever.

There's more to be said about the facts here, but I'll let that wait until Theo publishes. One important item though is the recording in which Susan was accused of using racist language. As the man who secretly made the tape knows, she was simply giving example of how language from a person of color would be misconstrued and recommending careful speech. The man who made the tape owned up to it in a later court filing, but it has disappeared. As it was made on RIOC time, it belongs to the state, but in response to a FOIL request, they told me they don't know anything about it. This means they have not case.

Theo Gobblevelt's avatar

David, my piece is out, but as hard as it is to admit, when I compare what Eleanor writes to what I do I find myself seeing how much she notices that I still have to work to reach.

David Stone's avatar

Eleanore is a subtle, careful observer. She catches and reports truths that usually escape me.

Theo Gobblevelt's avatar

Eleanor, your writing always puts me to shame. When I read it I feel like I was in the room: the way affection had a hierarchy, the laugh that turned into a camera cutting off, the careful silence that followed once her name came up. You give the texture of what actually happened.

I tried to pick up the legal thread you left open: the Second Circuit’s revival of her due-process claim and the steam tunnel that still has not been fixed. Worth reading next to this one: https://www.ri-lighthouse.com/p/rosenthal-vs-albany-the-steam-tunnel